Many vapers seek a substitute for smoking, whether it's from being new and needing something familiar, or simply because they enjoy tobacco cigarettes. The topic of analog-like vapes comes up frequently on web forums. I smoked pretty much my whole life, and I can relate. I will always want something that has that cigarette-like impact. I wake up every day and for the first couple hours of the day there is a particular juice I exclusively vape. If you're curious, for the longest time it was Vapor Station Tampa at 24mg and Halo Torque 56 the rest of the day, and recently Intellicig ECOpure Rich has become the top contender.
***update 28Nov2011
Well, after over a year of doing this, I am oddly attracted to pretty much the same juice that I liked when this was first written in 2010. I make my own juice now, but the juice I still vape all day every day are Vapor Station and Halo tobaccos. Great throat hit, clean burning, good flavors. Hard to beat for every day juices. These never leave my rotation, although they get temporarily joined by many of the juices you read about here. These two vendors are always present in The Juice Cellar.
So this is the Analog Replacement Sweepstakes, and the race is on to provide convincing, analog-like tobacco satisfaction for vapers who need it. Here are the front runners, in order of addition to the sweepstakes: